Is Overtime Taxed More? [Answered]

is overtime taxed more

There is a lot of debate surrounding the taxation of overtime compensation. Some believe that overtime should be taxed at a higher rate because employees are receiving extra compensation for working extra hours.

However, regardless of how you have earned your income, others believe that they should be taxed at the same rate. This post will look at the taxation of overtime pay by exploring frequently asked questions.

Does Overtime Get Taxed More?

The answer to this question is a bit complicated. Overtime pay is considered a type of income; therefore, it is taxable, just like your ordinary income. However, you may not pay taxes on all of your actual overtime earnings. The overtime pay on any extra income is subject to taxation and will depend on your tax bracket and the number of hours you work each week.

If you have any questions about how overtime is taxed or would like to look into additional resources, you should speak with a tax professional or the IRS.

Is Overtime Taxed Differently? 

If you are paid on a salaried basis, your employer is required to withhold taxes from your paycheck based on the IRS tax tables. Overtime pay is taxed at the same rate as your regular wage bracket, regardless of how many hours you work each week.

If your employer pays you on an hourly basis, they may not withhold taxes from your paycheck. You are held responsible for paying taxes on your overtime earnings. If you have a lower income, working large amounts of overtime could help increase your salary while still being in a lower tax bracket.

Forbes article for reference

👉Join 10,000+ Subscribers

Learn helpful tips to get out of debt and build wealth!

    We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

    How Overtime Is Taxed

    Example withholding taxes from overtime wages:

    If you are in the 25% tax bracket and earn $50 in overtime wages, your employer will withhold $12.50 from your paycheck for federal income taxes. If you are in the 15% tax bracket and earn $100 in overtime income, your employer will withhold $15 from your paycheck for federal income taxes.

    Overtime rate pay is subject to payroll taxes, Social Security, and Medicare taxes, just like regular wages. The current Social Security tax rate is 12.40%. The Medicare tax rate is currently set at Hospital Insurance (HI) – which is Part A of Medicare – at a rate of per person.”

    Overtime pay and the tax bracket myth explained:

    If you are in a higher federal income tax bracket, you may think that your overtime pay is taxed at a higher rate; this is not the case. Overtime pay is taxed at the same marginal rate as your base salary – regardless of your tax bracket. However, your overtime pay will be taxed higher if you are subject to state or local taxes on overtime earnings due to the burden of taxes.

    Therefore, while there is no “overtime tax,” you may still owe taxes on your overtime earnings. The amount of taxes you owe will depend on your tax bracket and the number of hours per week you work or your annual salary.

    Different states have different taxations for overtime compensation requirements. Some states tax overtime earnings at a flat rate, while others tax them at the same rate as regular wages. Some cities also have their ordinances regarding the taxation of earnings during overtime hours.

    For example, San Francisco imposes an additional “Parity Tax” on employers with more than 20 employees who do not offer health benefits to their employees. The tax is set on a per-hour basis, and the employer pays, not the employee. 

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Why do I pay more tax than my colleague?

    Your colleague may be in a lower tax bracket than you, so their overtime pay is taxed at a lower rate. They may not have any hours of overtime worked during the pay period or they are only making minimum wage. 

    I am an hourly employee, and I never see any taxes taken out of my paycheck. Is this normal?

    If you are an hourly wage employee, your employer is not required to withhold taxes from your paycheck. However, you are responsible for paying taxes on your earnings, including any overtime pay. Set aside money each week so that you can pay your taxes when they are due.

    How can I minimize the amount of taxes I owe on my overtime earnings?

    You can minimize the amount of taxes you owe by claiming deductions and credits on your tax return. Speak with a tax professional to see if there are any other strategies that you can use to lower your tax bill.

    In terms of taxes, Is working extra time worth it with all the taxes taken out?

    It depends on your circumstances. Lower tax bracket individuals, such as minimum wage employees, stand a chance of increasing their paycheck. However, if you are like most salaried employees in a higher tax bracket, you may not see as much increase in your paycheck when tax time comes.

    Therefore, it would be best to consider whether or not you will be subject to state or local taxes on your overtime earnings. A professional could help you estimate how much money you will take home after taxes and advise you on the best way to minimize your tax liability.

    Are there specific employees subject to overtime rules?

    There are exceptions to the overtime rules. Employees classified as exempt from the overtime rules are not entitled to overtime pay. It is the employer’s burden to prove the exempt status of employees. Exempt employees include executive, administrative, and professional employees and certain computer professionals, and outside salespeople.

    What is the difference between time-and-a-half and double-time?

    Time-and-a-half is when an employee receives one and a half times their regular hourly rate for each hour of Overtime worked. Double-time is when an employee gets twice their standard hourly rate for each hour of Overtime worked.

    Other employers offer employees the option to take paid time off (PTO) instead of receiving overtime pay. Suppose you have the chance to take PTO to calculate whether or not it is more beneficial for you to receive overtime pay or take PTO. Overtime pay can be a great way to boost your earnings, but it is essential to be aware of the taxes that you may take out of your paycheck.

    Additionally, Only government agencies and an employer of a nonexempt employee are permitted to offer compensatory time in place of overtime. The employer may not award comp time in place of paying overtime wages. 

    Do employers benefit from the overtime tax rules?

    The overtime tax rules benefit employers by helping them to control labor costs. By paying employees time-and-a-half for overtime hours, employers can save money on labor costs. In addition, the overtime tax rules may help discourage employees from working over 40 hours per workweek in an average workweek and prevent them from becoming burnt out.

    What are the consequences of not paying overtime taxes?

    You will be subject to penalties and interest. In addition, your employer may be liable for unpaid taxes, penalties, and interest. If you are an hourly adult worker your employer may also be required to pay a fine.