mercari review

Mercari Review [2020]: Our Experience

Last Updated on

Sharing is caring!

There are many places online where you can sell your clothing, as well as other items. The latest and greatest app is Mercari – and my wife is addicted to it. Because of this, I have decided to write a Mercari review.

But what exactly is Mercari and how does it all work? How does it compare to other marketplaces such as Poshmark? Before you ask any more questions, make sure you read our Mercari review. We’re going to tell you everything you need to know.

What Is Mercari?

Mercari is an online marketplace that allows you to buy and sell items. You can buy almost anything on the site, which means you can sell just about anything you can imagine on Mercari.

How To Get Started On Mercari

Signing up for Mercari was extremely easy. I was able to use my main email address or my Facebook account to create a profile.

sign up form for mercari

After signing up, they sent me a confirmation link and then I was able to access the platform.

Browsing The Platform

When I first logged in, I was pleasantly surprised at how simple it was to browse categories and search for specific items.

browse brands on mercari

In addition to being able to generally browse for items, Mercari also displays popular items in their main categories.

These suggestions were displayed into the following categories:

Authentic Handbags

mercari authentic handbags

Most of the items that were displayed were listed at around 70% less than retail price.

Deals For Her

mercari popular for her

Unfortunately, this is now where my wife spends the majority of her time. However, lucky for me the items are considerably cheaper than buying them from the store.

Deals For Him

Mercari doesn’t forget about the guys. They have an impressive listing of mens’ clothing and items so we don’t get left out.

Deals For the Kids

mercari deals for the kids

Am I the only one who likes browsing the kids section? Tell me I’m not alone in this…

Deals For The Tech Obsessed

Another of my favorite areas is the electronic section. In fact, my wife recently picked up 4 Amazon Echo devices for half off. Why did we need 4 Amazon Echos? I have no clue but apparently the price was too good to pass up.

Now I just need a place to put all of these things…

Kitchen And Dining

mercari kitchen and dining

Last but not least, they have a featured kitchen and dining section. Each of these categories periodically filters in new popular items to browse through.

Looking At Specific Items

What I liked about the Mercari platform is the ability to buy the item for the listed price or offer a lower price to the seller. Each seller lists their specific items at a “buy it now” price but with the mobile app you are given the opportunity to offer a lower price.

My wife has been successful several times by offering less than the asking price and the seller accepting.

make offer mercari

Another cool feature is the “like” button. It is a heart in the top corner of the photo of an individual item. We actually had a great experience with this feature.

My wife “liked” an item to remember to keep it for later. Well, it turns out that when you like an item, the seller is notified of your interest. Three days after liking the item, the seller sent us a message and offered to sell the item for a lower price.

Sweet!

Selling On Mercari

As for how it works for sellers, there are three main steps involved. They are:

Selling – Step 1

sell on mercari

Snap a photo or two of the item/items you want to sell. Then you’ll write a short description of it before setting its selling price.

Arrest Your Debt's Pro Tip:

Track your investments for free with Personal Capital. It's how I track my pension and retirement funds.

Don't Forget To Subscribe For My Latest Posts And Giveaways!

selling on mercari

Creating a descriptive and bold title is important as well as an accurate and complete description of your item. The more information you can write about the item you are selling – the better.

More information makes you look more authoritative and legitimate as a seller in order to demand top dollar for your items.

The next step is to place your item into a specific category to make it easier for people to find your item while browsing.

A brand and condition should also be entered. Keep in mind that you will not receive payment until after the buyer has rated you and the item.

So if your item is not new, make sure you accurately describe it or the buyer will not accept the item and you will be stuck trying to sell it again.

selling on mercari

In order to properly calculate shipping, you must enter your Zip Code. This will ensure accurate shipping calculations during the transaction.

Finally you get to set your requested price. Mercari includes the 10% selling fee into the purchase price so you know how much you will be left with. I really like this aspect of Mercari because if your item does not sell, you don’t owe anything.

name your price

You only pay Mercari when your item sells.

selling on mercari

Selling – Step 2

When your item is purchased, you’ll be sent an electronic packing and shipping label. Mercari pays for this, and all you have to do is print the label, pack, and ship the item.

Selling – Step 3

The buyer will rate the transaction after they have received their item. This is to protect the buyer so they can verify the item you sent is the one they bought.

After that, Mercari sends you your payment.

Buying On Mercari

I know I previously explained the buying process but I want to simplify it in three main steps.

Buying – Step 1

Buyers browse items that range from stuff like clothing to beauty products to novelty items and pretty much anything else you can think of.

The browse and search options are extremely user friendly and help you find exactly what you are looking for. Once you find that perfect item, it’s time to see if you can get it for the very best price.

Buying – Step 2

Buyers can either select the “Buy Button” to purchase the item for the requested price or they can use the mobile app to send a lower offer to the seller. If the purchase is approved, the seller will ship the order within three days.

Buying – Step 3

The final step involves rating the seller and the item. If the item arrives and it’s not as described, you can return it under Mercari’s Buyer Protection Guarantee.

However, if the product is as described, then the buyer’s payment is released.

As of now, there is no best price guarantee on Mercari. Some marketplaces have this policy, but Mercari currently does not.

In a worst-case scenario, you can request a refund or a return within three days of delivery.

Is Mercari Legitimate?

In the eCommerce space, there are scams everywhere. However, speaking from personal experience, Mercari is 100% legitimate.

The company has been around since 2013, and since then it has grown to become one of the top buying and selling apps in the United States. As of the time of this writing, the Mercari app has been downloaded just over 45 million times in the US.

Not only that, but an average of 150K listings are published every single day.

Another point we’d like to make is the rating the app has on Google Play. They maintain an average of 4.5 stars on the Google Play store. Their average App Store rating is 4.8 stars.

This means there are many satisfied buyers and sellers that use the app, which is a testament to Mercari’s legitimacy.

The bottom line is Mercari is not a scam. It is far from a scam, and it’s a great app to buy and sell just about anything.

Selling On Mercari – Is It Worth It?

Yes, it is worth it to sell your stuff on the app. Let me give you five reasons why:

Reason #1 – Popularity

As previously mentioned, the Mercari app has been downloaded over 40 million times and there are hundreds of thousands of users who buy and sell regularly using the app.

With so many potential buyers, you have a good chance of selling your items.

Reason #2 – Ease Of Use

Using Mercari as a seller is straightforward. You signup for an account, and once everything is set up you can list your items immediately.

Reason #3 – No Meetups

Have you ever tried to sell anything on Offer Up or Craigslist? I don’t know about you but I feel like a drug dealer meeting people on a corner – hoping they don’t jump me and take all my money.

Is Mercari safe? Absolutely – not having to meet up with the buyer is awesome.

Not having to physically meet buyers in person is one of the best reasons it’s worth selling on Mercari. Unlike selling on some apps, this eliminates the chances of encountering a risky situation or dealing with scammers who never had the intention of buying anything in the first place.

Reason #4 – You Can Make Good Money

Mercari offers you a way to make money fast. Whether it’s extra cash you’re after or you want to earn a good amount, the app gives you both opportunities.

Best of all, Mercari lets you make money from home or anywhere for that matter.

Reason #5 – You Can Start An Online Business

Many people use buying and selling apps as side hustles. However, you can use Mercari as a foundation for an online business.

You can do a bit of thrift buying online and then resell the items on Mercari. Remember, you don’t meet up with anyone and pre-printed shipping labels are used, which means you don’t spend your own money on shipping and labeling.

recent mercari seller reviews

How Much Mercari Charges

Mercari charges a 10% fee for each sale. It does not cost any initial money to list your items.

Also, there is a $2 fee if you want to receive a $10 or less direct deposit payment. If you want to be paid instantly, then you’ll be charged a $2 fee (not recommended).

If you want to avoid the fee for direct deposit, then don’t request payment until you have more than $10 in your Mercari account.

The 10% fee on sales is more than reasonable. Just make sure you keep the percentage they take in mind when the time comes to set your prices.

Mercari and Shipping Charges

Sellers have the option of either including the shipping in the price or having the buyers pay shipping separately. If you want to include free shipping, then you’ll be the one paying for it out of your sale.

Otherwise, it is the buyer who will pay shipping fees.

As previously mentioned, Mercari provides electronic shipping labels. However, you can choose to do everything on your own, but the company does request sellers to ship items within three days.

This means you’ll want to sort out where you’ll have the item shipped from (UPS, FedEx, etc. . .).

Why Mercari Shipping Is So Cheap

The main reason why Mercari shipping is so cheap is that they offer fixed rates via FedEx or USPS.

The fixed rates are for packages that weigh up to 150lbs, and the longer side can’t be more than 45 inches. The second-longest side can be no longer than 20 inches.

Items That Sell Best On Mercari

If you want to know how to make money, and a lot of it on Mercari, then you need to know what sells best on the app. The truth is that just about anything can be sold and does sell well. However, the best items that seem to sell appears to be electronics, clothing for babies and women, as well as handmade products.

Do you want to get paid to sell electronics and other products? It doesn’t matter what you want to sell, the chances are you can sell it on Mercari. If you take good photos of your items and write up good descriptions, then there’s a good chance your items will sell.

Items You Can’t Sell On Mercari

Call me Captain Obvious but you can’t sell anything that is illegal. Nor can you sell weapons, firearms, alcohol, drugs (legal or not), animals and things of that nature.

Most buying and selling platforms don’t allow you to sell items that fall within those categories.

Although this shouldn’t have to be said, Mercari doesn’t share personal data or sell it. This means you should never attempt to sell personal data via the platform.

Unfortunately, there are scammers everywhere and they even try to use Mercari to sell stuff they know they shouldn’t. If you’re in doubt as to whether or not you can list your item, then simply reach out to the Mercari team. They’ll be more than happy to tell you if you can or cannot sell your items on their platform.

Products Sold On Mercari

Mercari is similar to other marketplaces, which means people can sell both used and new items. You can sell your used electronics, used clothing and many other used items via the app.

The same goes for new stuff, but Mercari does suggest you set the price on new and unused items at around 70% of their original value. You are not required to do this but it’s a strong suggestion.

I Want To Sell – How Am I Protected?

mercari seller protection

There are several ways Mercari protects sellers. They offer a seller payment guarantee, which means if your product is delivered as promised, then you get paid.

In addition, you have shipping protection. Your items are insured for up to $200, and the insurance covers you if your items are damaged or lost in transit.

Mercari Gives You $10 For Signing Up!

A friend of mine introduced me to Mercari and I received a $10 dollar credit to use for my first purchase. If you’re interested in receiving a free $10 signup bonus you need to go through a referral link.

You’re in luck, I have a referral link for you here! (or click the image below)

free $10 on mercari

Mercari And Paypal

As a seller, you do not have the option to be paid via PayPal. Buyers are allowed to pay for items via PayPal, but sellers don’t have that option to get paid.

How Does Mercari Pay Me?

In order to receive payment, you need to link your bank account or debit card to the Mercari platform. With Instant Pay, you can request your money and have it in minutes on your debit card. Otherwise, you request your money and wait a period of time for it to arrive in your bank account.

Mercari does state they will let sellers know as soon as other payout options are available.

Mercari And Taxes

Buyers are required to pay sales tax if they are based in certain states. As of now, Mercari collects and remits sales taxes from sellers in 34 states. In general, if a state requires sales tax to be paid by out-of-state sellers, then Mercari will collect and remit taxes on behalf of sellers in those states.

Complaints About Mercari

OK, so nothing’s perfect so what’s the catch?

You’re right – while there are a bunch of positives to working with Mercari, there are also some common complaints.

A common complaint involves buyers rejecting items because they were not as described. Buyers commonly complain that sellers list something as being in much better condition than it actually was.

This allows the buyers to reject the item and the seller will not be paid. The item will be returned back to the seller to either relist or not sell.

At times sellers complain about their items not selling. This is usually due to attempting to sell new items at full price.

As I stated before, Mercari suggests you list items for 70% less than the suggested retail price because most buyers are not looking to purchase items at full price.

Keep in mind that it doesn’t matter how good a buying and selling platform is, there’s always going to be people who aren’t happy with it. This goes for both buyers and sellers.

Mercari vs. eBay – Which Is Better?

Compared to eBay, Mercari is definitely the underdog. Let’s see how the two compare.

Mercari

Mercari doesn’t charge high fees. They charge a flat rate of 10% per item sold and the app’s popularity continues to grow on a regular basis.

One great bonus is that Mercari provides the shipping labels to sellers – and at the time of this writing, eBay does not.

eBay

The online auction website eBay makes it easy, but not as easy as Mercari. However, eBay is the more popular site in terms of traffic. Although this does not necessarily mean most sellers are having more success with eBay than they are with Mercari.

In our opinion, Mercari is better. Bear in mind we’re not saying eBay is a bad site. However, we do think Mercari is the better of the two due to convenience and ease of buying and selling without a bidding process.

Mercari vs. PoshMark

PoshMark is fairly new, so there’s a lot of buzz surrounding it. So, is it better than Mercari? Let’s find out below:

Mercari

As mentioned several times, Mercari’s fee is only 10% per item sold. You can sell just about anything on the app. Not only that, PoshMark does not give you shipping labels, but Mercari does. You have the option to include shipping or you can charge the customer for shipping.

Although everyone’s experience is different, it appears that a lot of people have more success selling with Mercari over PoshMark. Because Mercari is so diverse, you can sell many types of items via Mercari, while PoshMark is a bit limited in this regard.

However, PoshMark does have a cleaner interface than Mercari. If you’ve never sold using Mercari, then you might find things to be a bit confusing at first.

PoshMark

Mercari caters to everyone, where PoshMark is catered to women for the most part. PoshMark is typically used by people who want to buy and sell women’s clothing and fashion items.

PoshMark is a bit more popular (compared to Mercari) among people looking to buy/sell women’s fashion items.

PoshMark is simple to use. Mercari is easy to use when you get the hang, but we think PoshMark is a bit easier to navigate. However, when it comes to fees PoshMark charges higher fees.

PoshMark charges up to 20% per item sold and around $7.00 is added to the buyer’s purchase. This is for shipping and handling.

In our opinion, Mercari is far better to use as a seller. When you sell via Mercari, you enjoy the chance to sell virtually anything, as well as access to hundreds of thousands of potential buyers. You don’t pay high fees and the company provides you with shipping labels.

These are a handful of reasons why Mercari is the better choice.

Our Overall Experience

I have bought and sold items on eBay, Offer Up, and Craigslist before and Mercari was by far the easier experience. If you’re looking for a way to clean out your closet and make a few extra bucks, you can’t go wrong by using Mercari.

The marketplace is popular and it is gaining even more popularity each day.

This means it will continue to be a top online marketplace to make money on the side, with the potential turn it into full-time income if you decide to use the site to sell items regularly.

Don’t forget, if you use this link here, you will get $10 dollars just for signing up.

Sharing is caring!

About The Author

Ryan Luke is a father of three, a husband, finance blogger, and full-time police officer. Through proper budgeting and money management, they have been able to live off one income and build wealth at the same time. As an active member of the personal finance community, his goal is to educate and help people get out of debt and build wealth!

6 thoughts on “Mercari Review [2020]: Our Experience”

  1. I have been selling on marcari for many years and I am getting disappointed. My sales has never been great and they come in spurks. I have not sold anything in 2 weeks now and like poshmark you can share and be active and your sells will come in but marcari. Shipping is not cheap on this site is very high. This is probably my second pick over poshmark and ebay. Also their app sucks it needs to be updated and organized. Thanks for the information but disagree to a lot of it. Any advice would be great to make things better on this site. Thanks

    1. Hey Kristy, thank you for the feedback! I have heard much of the criticism is from people having trouble selling items. However, it seems many of the complaints are from people listing their items too high and expecting others to pay full price. I agree with the app interface, it does need some help but they are still a relatively new company. So far we have not run into any of the obstacles you have but I like that Mercari gives you more flexibility to sell rather than being so focused on clothing like PoshMark.

  2. keepingupwiththebulls

    I have had a similar experience. Even when my items are priced lower on Mercari than Poshmark I still have always had an easier time selling on Poshmark. Perhaps that’s because most of what I sell is women’s clothing and the filters and UI are better on Poshmark. Both are definitely better than eBay for selling clothing. But, this is helpful information to know about Mercari. When something doesn’t sell quickly on Poshmark it’s good to have another possible platform to use.Thanks for compiling this information!

Leave a Reply